Skip to content

Answers to Objections: Index

Most people who hold to cessation hold it because of one or two of the objections below, not because they have worked out a system. Each page states its objection at its strongest and asks what follows from it. The table is a map; the pages do the work.

The eleven objections

Objection The claim at its strongest The short answer
Fallen Ministers and the Scandal Objection The movement's leaders keep falling; a bad tree bears bad fruit. Scripture records real gifts through wicked vessels. A scandal exposes the vessel, not the gift, and the same test would destroy any doctrine held by a sinful teacher.
Are the Miracles Demonic? This is counterfeit power; Satan produces signs. Counterfeits are real, but Scripture gives tests, and the blanket attribution repeats the Pharisees' error.
We Do Not See Them Today The gifts are not operating in the modern West, so they ceased. The premise is local and selective; Scripture diagnoses a scarcity of mighty works as unbelief; silence is not evidence of a divine act.
The Gifts Were Only for Authentication Signs attested the apostles and the new revelation, and the canon completed that work. Authentication is one purpose among several — edification, the common good, mercy — and the gifts are given to the whole body.
The Apostles Were Unique The apostolate was unrepeatable, and the gifts were its signs. Grant the uniqueness of the office; the gifts are not the office, and the New Testament church had prophets who were not apostles.
Experience Is Not Doctrine Continuationists argue from experience, which is subjective. Agreed — but the cessationist's lack of experience is also experience, and Scripture itself appeals to what the church has tasted.
Why So Much of It Is Fake Most of what is claimed is fraud, exaggeration, or suggestion. Much of it is, and the church should test and reform. But fraud is a fact about sellers, not about currency.
Tongues, Order, and Abuse The modern practice is chaotic, and Paul's rules show what it should be. Paul's rules regulate a practice he assumes is real and desirable; order is a command about use, not a verdict on existence.
The Canon Has Closed Revelation ended with the canon, so the revelatory gifts ended. The canon is closed; but New Testament prophecy is partial, judged, and subordinate, and it adds nothing to the foundation.
What About the Dead? If the gifts are for today, why do believers still die? Healing and raising are signs of the resurrection, not a substitute for it; the New Testament promises the redemption of the body at the last day.
Counterfeit Miracles: A Real Category Real signs can accompany false religion, so the gifts cannot be trusted. Scripture says so, and commands testing; the category cuts both ways, and this site sets Marian claims aside for exactly this reason.

How these pages argue

The objection is stated at its strongest. Not the version on a poster. Each page gives the argument its best premises and names its best defenders where I am confident of them. You should be able to recognise your own view in the second column.

The claim is separated from the caricature. Almost every objection contains a true concern attached to an inference that does not follow. "The gifts were for authentication" is true as far as it goes; the question is whether authentication was their only purpose. "Experience is not doctrine" is true, full stop; the question is whether the cessationist's experience of absence is exempt from his own rule.

What is conceded is conceded plainly. The casebook does not defend fraud, does not claim that every report is genuine, and does not promise that everyone who asks is healed.

If you have been hurt

Objections 1, 2, and 7 are often raised by the wounded, and the tone of the answer matters as much as its logic. If you watched a family emptied by a "seed faith" appeal, you are not being uncharitable by distrusting the movement. Read Fallen Ministers and the Scandal Objection first: it does not ask you to defend what you saw.

See also